Which is Better for Fat Loss?

Settling the Cardio vs. Weights Debate

Which is Better for Fat Loss? - Settling the Cardio vs. Weights Debate
You’re probably familiar with the ongoing arguments pitting strength training against cardio training, arguing that one is better than the other for fat loss.

A study published in the Journal of Applied Physiology looked at the effects of aerobic and/or resistance training on body mass and fat mass in overweight or obese adults. In the study, 119 sedentary, overweight or obese adults were randomized to one of three eight-month exercise protocols: 1) RT: resistance training, 2) AT: aerobic training, and 3) AT/RT: aerobic and resistance training (combination of AT and RT). The researchers found that a program of combined aerobic training and resistance training did not result in significantly more fat mass or body mass reductions over aerobic training alone.

If you’re willing to extrapolate these outcomes and recommendations to also include non-obese, active individuals, aerobic (cardio) training appears to be the optimal mode of exercise— over resistance training— for reducing body fat.

Now, these results are only half of the training puzzle because you don’t just want a “lean” physique; you want a lean and muscular physique. And, in order to achieve the “muscular” part, you’ve got to do resistance training, which is why the researchers of this study also stated that “a program including Resistance Training is needed for increasing lean muscle mass.”

In this article, I’m going to describe the basic physiology principles you need to know about cardio and strength training, and show you how to combine cardio and strength training in a unique and effective way to help you build a leaner and more muscular physique.

Cardio and Fat Loss Myth-busting

Although any type of physical activity can have positive health benefits, the benefits of steady-state cardio training from a fat loss (without muscle loss) perspective is often very misunderstood, and research like the study mentioned above can often add to that confusion.

In order for you to understand why common statements like “If you want to burn fat, do cardio” are deceiving, you must first have a clear understanding of what steady-state cardio training is, and what it isn’t!

Once you understand what it is, you can better understand what it does and doesn’t do for you. In that, you’ll have a clearer understanding of the benefits and the limitations of steady-state cardio training.

Aerobic vs. Anaerobic Training

You’ve probably heard the terms aerobic training, which means “with oxygen,” and anaerobic training, which means “without oxygen.”

Put simply: cardio = aerobic training, and metabolic strength training = anaerobic training.

The main thing that separates aerobic from anaerobic training is intensity. Here’s a simple, real-world example to help you better understand this: Let’s say you and a friend are jogging together. While you are jogging you are carrying on a normal conversation. If you’re able to speak in normal sentences without any huffing and puffing between words, it means you’re in an “aerobic state.” However, if you both decide to pick up the pace and speed up to a fast run or sprint, sure you’ll still be to talk to one another, but you’ll be unable to get out full sentences without huffing and puffing, which means you’re now in an “anaerobic state.”

The example just given is called “The Talk Test.” It’s a very simple, but legitimate method of telling whether you’re in anaerobic or anaerobic state.

It’s that simple: If you’re able to speak a full sentence when doing cardio-type activities like running, jump rope, etc., as you normally would, you’re still in an aerobic state. But, if you have to take a breath (or a few breaths) during a single sentence, you’re in an anaerobic state.

Cardio Does Not Exclusively Burn From Your Fat Stores!

When you’re in an anaerobic state, your body exclusively burns glycogen, which is basically what your body transfers carbohydrates into after you consume them. Glycogen is synthesized and stored mainly in the liver and the muscles. And, it’s your body’s preferred energy source.

However, when you’re in an aerobic state, your body has many options available to use (burn) as energy. In an aerobic state, your body can burn from glycogen, fat and muscle tissue. Put simply, sure cardio training can and does burn fat, but it can also burn glycogen or even muscle tissue as well, which is why very few (if any) endurance athletes (like runners and cyclists) have much muscle mass.

Also, with the above physiology in mind, it’s easy to see how cardio training burns more overall calories than resistance training. But, the fact is it still doesn’t mean that all you need to do is cardio. It just means that if fat loss is your goal, you probably need to add it in addition to strength training.

In other words, as stated above, cardio training is just one piece to the puzzle.

Nick Tumminello is the owner of Performance University fitness training and education in Fort Lauderdale, FL. He’s the author of the “Core Training: Facts, Fallacies & Top Techniques” 3-DVD set. Nick also writes a popular training blog at www.PerformanceU.net.